Anthony Selm is the Co-President of The Modern Insurance Store.
Since 2013, Anthony has been proudly helping retirees, self-employed individuals and small business owners navigate Medicare, health and life insurance. With nearly two decades of insurance industry experience, he utilizes an education-first, concierge-style approach to ensure clients make confident, informed decisions that help give them peace of mind.
Anthony’s focused leadership has helped The Modern Insurance Store grow and thrive. The agency serves agents and clients across more than two dozen states and works to make expert guidance feel as personal as having an agent next door — no matter the distance. Guided by his motto, “Being a person of integrity is doing the right thing all the time, every time,” Anthony prioritizes trust, transparency and exceptional service in every interaction.
Anthony lives in Bethel, Ohio, with his wife and their three sons. Outside of work, he enjoys hiking, skiing, mountain biking, music and coaching.